The triangle of violence expressed by johan galtung. According to giorgio gallo and arturo marzano the clear. Pdf educational value of johan vincent galtungs conflict. A critical analysis of positive and negative peace oshadhi herath department of philosophy, university of kelaniya abstract peace is a small word with a deeper meaning attached to it different interpretations, different perspectives and different understandings yet the meaning is one but for one s own self. It is a book to start the road with and to return to by the end of the road democratization galtungs book is one of the best guides for getting to know the world we. Resistance, power and conflict goteborgs universitet. Jul 24, 2017 galtungs conflict triangle 1969 is one of the influential models in contemporary conflict resolution. Oct 21, 2015 johan galtungs conflict transformation theory for peaceful world. The british took some reformative initiatives that ostensibly deserve appreciation such as the development of a predictable legal system. To read more about jonathan galtungs work, including the conflict triangle, positive peace, negative peace, etc, click here. Understanding violence triangle and structural violence. However, models such as galtungs conflict triangle are included here, regardless. When the actual is unavoidable, then violence is not present even. It is true that there is a relationship with structural violence as there is between interpersonal violence and structural violence.
Anything galtung forum understanding galtungs violence. Providing a wideranging panorama of the ideas, theories, and assumptions on which the study of peace is based, peace by peaceful means gives a theoretical foundation for peace research, peace education, and peace action. Perceiving theory and a triangle that i plan to use in my. According to galtungs violence triangle 1969, cultural and structural violence cause direct violence. The inner and outer reactions are not necessarily at the same temperature murder in cold blood, boiling inside. Peacebuilding fundamentals catholic relief services. With the french thinker michel foucaults conception of power and domination, a reinterpretation of galtungs famous concepts of structural violence and positive and negative peace is called for. Both types of violence, therefore, need to be justified or legitimated in one form or another. According to giorgio gallo and arturo marzano the clear separation is only useful in order to theoretically understand and explain a conflict. Professor at the department of peace and conflict research, uppsala university, uppsala, sweden. Johan galtung and provides an excellent basic concept for the analysis of. This discussion examines the work of galtung on the idea of cultural violence and how this has influenced our understanding of conflicts. To transform a conflict between some parties, more than a new architecture fo r their relationship is needed.
The conflict triangle is a tool to help analyse the basic elements of a conflict situation by placing them in a triangular relationship, where each element influences and is influenced by the others. There is also the violence frozen into structures, and the culture that legitimizes violence. This occurs in the arena of culture, in the realm of beliefs, attitudes, and symbols. Galtungs conflict triangle 1969 is one of the influential models in contemporary conflict resolution. What links here related changes upload file special pages permanent link page. This article is a short version of a text which was first published with the title nonviolent conflict escalation in conflict resolution quarterly, 2016. It reflects the normative aim of preventing, managing, limiting and overcoming violence. Introductionwhere marx believed that social class is the most basic division in any society, max weber saw conflict as having many possible bases religion, race, ethnicity, and more including social class. Galtungs conflict triangle johan galtung we understand that violence is any physical, emotional, verbal, institutional, structural or spiritual behaviour, attitude, policy or condition that diminishes, dominates or destroys others and ourselves. Our investigation will begin by analysing violence and how it is affiliated to structural violence. Johan galtungs conflict transformation theory paperblog. A word of warning when we talk about theories of international relations such as realism and liberalism, it is tempting to make statements such as the usa is realist or the netherlands use liberal theory.
Pathak, bishnu 2014 johan galtungs conflict transformation theory for peaceful world. The unit sections explore key concepts including the distinctions between conflict. Pdf this article will explore the educational value of johan vincent galtungs thoughts on conflict. Peace and conflict, development and civilization edition 1. To read more about jonathan galtungs work, including the conflict triangle, positive peace, negative peace, etc. Direct violence, physical andor verbal, is visible as behaviour in the triangle. Violence, peace, and peace research by johan galtung international peace research institute, oslo 1.
Discuss johan galtungs concept of cultural violence and consider critically its. This article utilizes a threepronged analytical model to examine the mechanics of british colonialism and its socioeconomic and political consequences in india. Introducing some tools this session focused on introducing some theory and toolkits for the participants to use on existing and personal conflicts. This represents a clear contrast to competitive diplomacy and war, the coercive approaches to conflict traditionally used on the international level, which often serve only to perpetuate bitterness and asymmetry. The number of universities offering peace and conflict studies courses is hard to estimate, mostly because courses may be taught out of different departments and have very different names. Galtungs structural violence and the sierra leone civil. The socalled abc triangle in conflict theory galtung 1967, 1996 is used to explain how conflict escalates and how the different components of conflict are interlinked. Causal flows can start anywhere, but generally in c, the contradiction. This incisive volume is organized into four parts, each of which studies one of the four major theoretical approaches to peace. The book is organized in four parts, each examining the one of the four major theoretical approaches to peace. Furthermore, since the conflict triangle focuses on each partys perceptions separately, it is a highly recommended tool to analyse multiparty conflicts. In 2006, icco initiated a baseline study to provide a systematic and critical overview of its current efforts and results in the field of conflict transformation in africa and the middle east.
The parties may be inside a person, a state or nation, a region or civilization, pulling in different directions. This brief overview of johan galtungs life and work begins with some of his childhood experiences such as his father being imprisoned in a nazi concentration camp that shaped his determination to work for peace. Galtungs successful role in a 1990s conflict between peru and ecuador illustrates the potential of the transcend method. Introduction in the present paper we shall be using the word peace very many times. And structural violence is the most problematic area to be addressed for conflict transformation. Johan galtung a principal founder of the discipline of peace and conflict studies duration. Edinburgh cyrenian trust, a registered charity in scotland, number sc011052 the conflict triangle. Direct violence reinforces structural and cultural violence. The british took some reformative initiatives that ostensibly deserve appreciation such as the development of a predictable legal system, investment in. After giving a brief description of the galtung conflict triangle and short asymmetry and symmetry analysis, i will examine the nagorno karabakh conflict using. This abc attitudebehaviourcontext conflict triangle was first developed by prof. A critical analysis of positive and negative peace oshadhi herath department of philosophy, university of kelaniya abstract peace is a small word with a deeper meaning attached to it different interpretations, different perspectives and different understandings yet the meaning is one but for ones own self.
Galtungs structural violence and the sierra leone civil war c. The pioneering professor of peace and conflict research, johan galtung, was the first to coin the phrase structural violence. Where marx believed that class inequalities would ultimately be ended by revolution, weber saw conflict as eternal, although it could take new forms. Peace and conflict studies today is widely researched and taught in a large and growing number of institutions and locations. Strategy, a more narrow term, is the broad plan of action for the overall struggle, including the development of an advantageous situation, the. Following that, a comprehensive discussion on galtungs violence triangle will be presented in order to lead the discussion onto the strengths and weaknesses of galtungs. The c corner of the triangle represents the core issue the contradiction that causes a. Galtung first introduced the conflict theory triangle in his article violence, peace, and peace research. After giving a brief description of the galtung conflict triangle and short asymmetry and symmetry analysis,i will examine the nagorno karabakh conflict using the models three axes structural, cultural social. Scottish centre for conflict resolution improving relationships, improving lives information sheet the sccr has been made possible by funding from the third sector early intervention fund. Galtung s successful role in a 1990s conflict between peru and ecuador illustrates the potential of the transcend method.
Conflict analysis tools understanding and working with. There are many misunderstandings and unfortunate conceptions of conflict, that great creator and great destroyer. Participants first presented their ideas of what conflict analysis was, power relations finding a solution understanding the conflict predicting outcome understanding the parties the facilitator then introduced two. Pdf the galtung triangle and nagornokarabakh conflict taleh. It would be erroneous to say that culture is the root cause of violence, since the causal influence runs bilaterally among the three corners of the violence triangle. Stalenoi, in their article th e peoples warand johan galtungs conflict models, applies this theory to the civil war in nepal, which they identify as an asymmetric conflict. Structural violence as a human rights violation kathleen ho abstract. Conflict is much more than what meets the naked eye as trouble, direct violence. The first triangle follows the attitudes, contradictions and the conflict. Processes of conflict in the world in the 1980s, translated by aadne goplen. Johan galtung on solutions in conflict transformation youtube. After giving a brief description of the galtung conflict triangle and short asymmetry and symmetry analysis,i will examine the nagorno karabakh conflict. Pdf disarmament, demobilization and reintegration ddr is a critical element of post conflict peace building pcpb. Conflict analysis tools understanding and working with conflict.
Lecture transcript and video of galtungs speech at the joan b. Johan galtung, one of the founders of modern peace studies, provides a wideranging panorama of the ideas, theories and assumptions on which the study of peace is based. The major road to peace is conflict transformation where conflict uproots along with goals in contradiction and conflict. I expect that shift in context, perhaps gaining more economic stability or even moving to a more metropolitan area, might dramatically shift someones attitude and behavior. Johan galtungs conflict triangle works on the assumption that the best way to define peace is to define violence, its opposite. The basic point is that peace is a relation, between two or more parties. Someone congratulated his parents saying, today a new doctor is born. Peace and conflict studies academic dictionaries and. The principal founder of the peace and conflict studies johan galtung was born in oslo on october 24, 1930 at a medical doctors family. In this longer article you can find references to all our sources.
However, models such as galtung s conflict triangle are included here, regardless. In other words, when the potential is higher than the actual is by definition avoidable and when it is avoidable, then violence is present. Oct 12, 2012 galtungs structural violence and the sierra leone civil war c. Johan galtungs conflict transformation theory for peaceful world.
A mini theory of peace tfftransnational foundation for. May 06, 2018 a short overview of galtung s conflict triangle. A contradiction left unresolved leads to accumulation of negative energies in the a and b. Apr 15, 20 the conflict triangle can be used as a tool to analyse a conflict as a dynamic process in which structurescontext, attitudes and behavior constantly change and influence each other. Foucault and galtung on structural violence irenees. Human rights and peacebuilding after the war, with its egregious violations of human rights, it turned out that both victims and offenders had to continue to live in the same village as before the war. Johan galtung on solutions in conflict transformation. Few words are so often used and abused perhaps, it seems, because peace serves as a means of obtainingverbal consensusit is hard to. Galtung and the conflict triangle chapman peace studies. The humanitarian family human rights and peacebuilding are deeply practical and political fields, besides their formal institutionalization through, for instance, a legal andor constitutional system of a state.
In johan galtungs 1969 paper, violence, peace and peace research, he presents his theory of the conflict triangle, a framework used in the study of peace and conflict, with the. Those three elements are divide and rule, colonial education, and british laws. Galtungs theory of structural violence sociology essay. It is a simplified model of johan galtungs thinking on the relationship between. Johan galtung is widely acknowledged as the founder of peace studies and. Johan galtung, the father of peace studies springerlink. Stalenoi the peoples war and johan galtungs conflict models 34 and in a conflict more than one type of asymmetry may exist, each with variable degrees of intensity. Audio recordings with johan galtung in the online archive of the osterreichische mediathek interviews and lectures in german. Following that, a comprehensive discussion on galtungs violence triangle will be presented in order to lead the discussion onto the strengths and weaknesses of galtungs theory of structural violence.
698 1219 434 674 1306 528 716 997 599 886 600 1007 172 488 1224 1233 435 970 803 903 379 1556 764 1528 1575 918 1210 29 928 338 232 1214 65 1219 1445 145